Leggy, karaoke-singing Allegra Thome spends her days teaching dysfunctional teens and her nights with wealthy new boyfriend, Michael. The rough patch following Allegra’s divorce is over, and life is grand. But when Allegra lands in the middle of a drug bust and meets Sloan, a rough-around-the edges DEA agent and, later that day, a throwaway kid from her class disappears, things quickly head south. Sloan, who has the tact of a roadside bomb, is attracted to Allegra and alienates Michael. To make matters worse, nobody seems to care that Allegra’s student, Sara Stepanek, is missing.

Add to the mix a rural Washington State town under the spell of a charismatic minister who doesn’t hesitate to use secrets of the rich and powerful to keep them in line, even while withholding his own dark past, and Allegra’s search for Sara becomes a race against time with dead bodies piling up and her own life in peril. Under the circumstances, it’s not surprising things come to a head at the WWJD (What Would Jesus Drink) Winery.